M.My colleague Skip was the family doctor I always wanted to be. He could riff like an impromptu jazz musician, assessing patients with new joint or liver inflammation. I was able to identify. I went to see Skip when I got the baffling test results. He sat down in his chair, turned his thoughts around a bit, and understood the findings.
Six months before the Covid-19 pandemic hit, Skip died by suicide.at him memorial service, a friend described Skip’s dedication to patients. He overheard Skip telling his wife that he was going home and cooking dinner, but he took a series of phone calls with a patient that made him miss dinner altogether. The patient described how Skip double-booked into his schedule or went home to see him when he was sick.
None of these stories dampened my admiration for Skip. In fact, they demonstrated the ideals of patient care that inspire many primary care physicians. But they deeply conflicted me, and I’ve been grappling with Skip’s legacy, especially now that he’s become the unit chief of the department he worked for.
advertisement
Suicide is complicated, and I know other issues contributed to Skip’s death. And I realized that many of the attributes that Skip admired (dedication, accessibility, dedication) may have hurt him.
Covid-19 has swept Chelsea, Massachusetts. This community, served by our health center, is like a fire in the dry grass. The adrenaline got me through the initial surge. But over time, the pandemic has exacerbated the essential dysfunction of primary care.
advertisement
As a unit chief, I see the added burden of the last few years weighing on all kinds of colleagues. Although the focus here is on the physician in his primary care, the theme of this essay applies to all types of health care practitioners.
Patients are messaging clinicians through more online portals than ever before, and after years of skipping appointments, their condition is getting worse. I have text his chain of friends from medical school, all of whom are primary care physicians. We regularly take surveys with each other.pleasantly crispy, or pile of ash smoke?” We joke, but humor masks fear.
Burnout and depression are separate entities, but the two certainly overlap. And as clinicians’ in-baskets swell with post-corona demand, friends and colleagues are doing more than ever to reach out to realize an idealized vision of primary care that is becoming increasingly unrealistic. It’s terrifying to see yourself sacrificed.
Primary care is very important. basic, to healthcare.still remains lack of resourcesThere is a yawning gap, further widened by the pandemic, between practicing primary care the way it was resourced and doing it the way patients deserved it. Most primary care physicians spend hours filling that gap. Personal time on patient care, stay up late replying to messages, reviewing and sharing test results. I accepted it. Because that’s what the patient needs.
From day one of medical school, doctors are taught that the patient comes first — everytimeUntil Skip died, I never thought about every single choice my colleagues and I make to put our patients first — one more phone call, another hour at the computer, and more. I missed one more family dinner — and never thought about how much these choices would cost me as I scaled them throughout my career. should not mean
And yet, yes. The sum of these small choices erode your mental health. the doctor Maximum charge Suicide in any occupation, and almost half Of them develop depression by the end of training.As physician and author Elizabeth Poorman convincingly argues, depression and suicide are Industrial accident to practice medicine.
Since Skip’s death, I have not given up on my primary care commitments. I am keenly aware that I am jeopardizing the future of
I have found that an important part of my role is to encourage the doctors I work with to not put too much effort into their work. very few. Our budget does not allow us to hire as many additional staff members as we may need.
However, I can Change is how you talk to your colleagues about work. It can be said that widely accepted primary care expectations are almost entirely ambitious. We can change the stories we tell ourselves about what it means to be a good primary care provider. And new archetypes can be established. It is a physician empowered to practice medicine sustainably in a way that can be continued year after year, with diligent patient care.
In several ways, I have tried to engage my colleagues in discussions about sustainable primary care practices. First and foremost, we encourage patients to set limits. Many primary care providers are hesitant to set boundaries because medical training equates to putting patients’ needs first and providing excellent care. But, like other aspects of primary care, such as population health best practices, best practices for setting boundaries with patients need to be discussed and shared.
This may include limiting the visit agenda to three topics for patients who bring many concerns to each visit. Alternatively, it may include limiting the amount of time spent responding to messages received via the patient portal. Many messages can be answered by other members of her team, but if a doctor needs to respond, they should only respond to messages when they have time during working hours. Please do not respond at night or on weekends. Longer conversations about test results should be scheduled as virtual visits. So even if the conversation is delayed, that time is reflected in clinical productivity.
Many hospitals and healthcare systems ask patients to review their healthcare providers. I rather feel that my work is sustainable, with doctors who have negative comments from patients that visits are too short or that results take too long to come back. I would like to work. doctor.
I have also tried to emphasize the sustainability of primary care by encouraging my colleagues to adopt team-based care. The team is not yet realized for doctors. Achieving this will depend on a regional leader like myself working more effectively and incorporating a well-trained team and his members into all workflows. But the opposition to this is that low reimbursement for primary care is a barrier to many practices hiring strong managers and well-staffed teams.
However, I believe that some primary care providers still harbor a desire to fulfill the archaic archetype of the archaic doctor who is solely responsible for all aspects of patient care. It is time to have the humility to recognize and accept that team members lack the talents and skills they bring to patient care.
Indeed, such efforts are just a drop in the bucket. Frontline clinicians and community leaders cannot solve the real problem: the structure of the U.S. healthcare system. If payers and provider organizations want patients to spend more time with their primary care provider and have same-day, personal communication via portal messaging, they can increase primary care reimbursement so providers can We need to be able to spend more time and hire staff to help manage those portals. And if teams are the future of primary care, we need significantly more funding to support, train, and maintain these teams.
I often wonder if policy makers and health professionals make the difficult choices necessary to improve primary care. Recently, I finished seeing a patient who has been taking care of me for many years. Every time I gave her the Covid-19 vaccine, she complained, worried about what she had heard from friends and family, even though I had reassured her. He arched my perfectly penciled eyebrows and said:
We in primary care want to give our patients the time, effort, excellence and passion that SKIP invests in them every day.
Audrey Provenzano is a Primary Care Physician, Unit Chief of Adult Medicine at MGH Chelsea Health Care Center, and Medical Instructor at Harvard Medical School.
If you or someone you know may have suicidal thoughts, please contact 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: call or text 988 or chat 988lifeline.orgFor TTY users: Use your preferred relay service or dial 711 then 988.
First Opinion Newsletter: If you love reading opinion and perspective essays, get our weekly First Opinion Roundup delivered to your inbox every Sunday. SIGN UP HERE.
