Tim Winard knew he needed to buy health insurance when he left management in manufacturing to launch his own business.
It was the first time he had shopped for the press and looked for plans to cover him and his wife.
“We were very nervous that the company didn’t have plans to offer,” Winard said.
After talking to the insurance agent, he opposed signing up for an affordable care law plan, as he was worried about the potential costs. Instead, he opted for a short-term policy. This is good for six months.
Six months later, Winard was still working on starting his business, so he signed up for another insurance company and another short-term policy, which cost around $500 a month.
When he needed a colonoscopy, 57-year-old Winard called his insurance company. He said the representative told him to go to any facility he wanted for the proceedings.
Earlier last year, he underwent colonoscopy at a hospital in Elmhurst, Illinois, not far from his Addison home.
The steps went smoothly and soon afterwards Winard went home.
Then came the bill.
Medical procedures
Regular colon cancer screening is recommended for people at average risk starting at age 45 and continuing until age 75. US Preventive Services Task Force. In addition to those intended for preventive purposes, doctors can order colonoscopy to diagnose existing concerns, as in the case of Weinard.
There are several methods, including non-invasive stool testing. a Colonoscopy is permitted The clinician examines and removes the polyps and is then tested to see if they are precancerous or malignant.
Final bill
Includes $10,723.19, anesthesia is $1,436 and $1,039 in the recovery room. After the insurance discount, his plan paid $817.47. Winard was left for $7,226.71.
Short-term, limited-term insurance policies do not need to follow rules established under the ACA. This is because the ACA is intended for temporary compensation only.
As Winard has experienced, benefits within a plan vary, and setting a certain dollar cap for certain types of healthcare can be costly. What’s covered can be difficult to analyze, and insurance companies generally receive the last word interpreting the rule.
While some short-term policies appear to be comprehensive major health policies, all have been given serious attention. Most people may be surprised to find that people who are used to work-based or comprehensive ACA plans.
For example, all short-term insurers can screen applicants for health status and reject them due to health issues or rule out those status. Many people do not include drug compensation or obstetric care.
The fact that short-term plans can cover fewer services, conditions and patients is why they are cheaper than generally unsubsidized ACA plans.
“We’re excited to announce that we’re a health information nonprofit organization that includes KFF Health News,” said Cynthia Cox, vice president and director of KFF ACA programs. “However, the reason the price of short-term plans is lower than comprehensive ACA plans is because they don’t need to denial people with existing conditions and cover many important health benefits.”
He was surprised he owed more than $7,000 for a colonoscopy, but Winard contacted his insurance company, Companion Life Insurance, in Columbia, South Carolina.
The insurance representative told him via email that he had categorized all costs, including procedures and anesthesia, based on the benefits of the “outpatient surgery facility” in his insurance contract.
The advantage was that it limited the payment of insurance “inside the facility” to a maximum of $1,000 per day.
That definition said he read his policy that it means that there is a cap in what he can claim to the facility itself, and he read his policy, not all the care he received there.
“I interpreted it as a facility like a recovery room or an operating room,” he said. “They defined the inclusion of services in outpatient facilities.”
According to his plan, after patients meet deductibles, they cover screening for colon cancer at 80%. It also covers 80% of the cost of drugs offered in an outpatient setting.
Winard, who had met the deduction, said he expected to pay only 20% for the cost of a colonoscopy. However, he also wondered why the screening conducted at Endeavor Health Elmhurst Hospital was classified by the insurance company as a procedure in a “outpatient” facility.
According to emails received from his insurance company, the $1,000 per day limit in his policy applies to “treatment or services at a state’s independent outpatient surgery center or hospital outpatient surgery facility that is not part of a hospital.”
Elmhurst Health spokesman Allie Burke said the hospital comes with a building where same-day outpatient surgery can be performed, such as colonoscopy.
Short-term plans have been on sale for decades. However, in recent years they have become political football.
Concerns that people would choose them with more comprehensive ACA insurance, President Barack Obama’s administration has limited the short-term plan term to three months. These rules were lifted during President Donald Trump’s first term, allowing the plan to be sold again as a 364-day policy.
President Joe Biden, Such a plan is called “junk insurance.” We have limited our policy to four months. This is a change that took effect one month after the Winard process. Trump is expected to turn Biden’s comeback and make them available for long term use again.
Solution
In December, Winard hired advocate Linda Michaelson to help him parse the bill. They wrote to the hospital and offered to pay $4,000 if they resolve the entire bill. Michaelson said that it’s about four times more Medicare pays for colonoscopy. Winard said the hospital refused the offer.
Another Elmhurst spokesman, Spencer Walrath, emailed KFF Health News that the prices of the hospital “reflect the value of the services we offer.”
Companion Life did not respond to requests for comment. Scott Wood, who identified himself as a program manager and co-founder of Pivot Health, which sells companion life and other insurance plans, said in an interview that there was room for interpretation of the claims and asked Companion Life to take a different view.
Shortly after Wood’s comment on KFF Health News, Winard said he was contacted by his insurance company. The representative told him that when he reconsidered, the bill had been adjusted, but he was not given a specific explanation as to why.
His new bill showed he owed only $770.
Take home
Short-term planning is attractive to some people because of the relatively low cost of premiums. But consumers should read All plans should be carefully documented before registering. Understand that in many cases, planning does not cover all the benefits, and see which services are covered and which are excluded. Please check if your policy includes a daily or per-policy dollar limit for coverage or other payment restrictions.
The federal government provides grants based on ACA plan household income. This allows for even more affordable and even short-term planning, but offers a wide range of benefits.
In hindsight, Winard said he didn’t understand the difference between ACA policies and short-term planning.
His advice? Before non-emergency procedures such as colonoscopy, do not rely solely on marketing materials and always get a written cost estimate.
KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces detailed journalism on health issues and is one of KFF’s core operating programs. It is an independent source of health policy research, voting and journalism. Please see more KFF.
Copyright 2025 Health News Florida
