T.Like the “delinquent” teens, or boys who called themselves “freaks” in the turmoil of the early ’90s, they were part of something special, some kind of revolution. I can feel one thing. At least, this time it was a big shift in youth culture. For me, the most amazing thing about that period was the powerful, strange and beautiful musicians I had with me through my tumultuous youth. I always felt very lucky because of that. I know that every era has its musical heroes, but I think there was something really special about 90s music. As I have written before, music is a very important part of my life and healing.
The 90s had a lot of particularly brave female artists. But Sinead O’Connor, or Shuhada Sadakat (the name she adopted after converting to Islam in 2018), may have been the boldest and most unique of all musicians at the time. She’s from Dublin, and just in case, on night TV, she’s confronted the Pope.
When I first heard a song like Nothing compares to 2 U Like so many of us, I was riveted by her voice and her strength on the radio.but she tore up the pope’s photo The anger of young girls around the world experiencing patriarchal oppression in protest against sexual abuse within the church was right there, right there on TV. As a young girl, it was shocking to see such courage. My friends and I thought that refusing to shave our legs and listening to Riot Grrrl’s band was the best protest we could muster, but she was totally unimaginable and irresistible. I was doing something unbearably extreme.
Once I entered adolescence, my life quickly changed to that of a psychiatric abuse survivor. I became an angry woman in my early twenties who was diagnosed as “insane.” Like me, she too was diagnosed with bipolar disorder in her early 2000s (later she said her bipolar disorder was a misdiagnosis and not bipolar). I still think Sinead is an unparalleled bravery when it comes to public protest music and performance in our time. But not many know how she came to terms with her prejudices and psychiatry.
When I became a mental health activist, I encountered the following: A pleading video she released from a New Jersey hotel in 2017, and the thought quickly crossed my mind of how often psychiatry is being used to silence those with strong extremist views. It certainly wouldn’t be the first time an angry woman has been ravaged by prejudice, isolation, and chemical restraint for her feelings, thoughts, and views. It’s actually as old as psychiatry itself.Quote from this movie review crazy woman’s ball The CNN show is worth picking up. We are familiar with this story. “It’s an old story. Women don’t conform to social norms, traditional notions of femininity, or what is expected of them, and are ignored as sick.” She is considered hysterical. ing. As such, she would either be imprisoned, burned at the stake, covered up, or perhaps placed under greater male control. “
And of course, this kind of targeting isn’t just limited to women. Certainly, people of color, Indigenous people, queer people, and trans people all go through this.
I started to find out what happened to this bold and highly creative protest singer in my youth when I found her videos online. In my mind, Sinead brought a new light to her life and her music, a new understanding of her and my suffering. I felt her closeness and solidarity with her, as many who have struggled with her loneliness, suicidal thoughts and her prejudices must have felt.
We sometimes think about what we perceive as judging, encroaching on, and endlessly arrogating the private lives of artists. Because they gave us works that felt vulnerable and raw. But I am writing this in the spirit of protest against Sinead’s injustice. Not only did she remind me, as a teenager, to be brave and create art that countered the injustices of the world, but as a grown woman, I was labeled as mentally ill. It reminded me not to keep quiet about the abuse that is happening to people who are in the middle of the day. Over the years, she has spoken out about corruption in Israel/Palestine, abortion, sexual abuse, the church, and even the Grammy Awards, but this video explores her and many others’ experiences in combating these issues. He spoke out loud about the neglect and suffering he suffered. Trauma, prejudice, suicidal thoughts.
She was one of millions, she repeated in the video, was one of millions.
And she was right. Just like she was right about sexual abuse in church. In a way no other musician has, she has spoken out about the impact her diagnosis, prejudice, and psychiatry had on her life, and how she was abandoned and abandoned by the world and her family at the time. was raising
Watching this video made me interested in her music again. And when she died, I had her music playing all day long. She was a very powerful creative person. After the video was released in 2017, the media reported her sentiments as “Cinead is raising concerns for her mental health.” To me, this was yet another courageous and powerful protest, ripping off a photo of the Pope, but this time showing the pain and neglect suffered by those labeled as mentally ill. I thought that Many seem to see the plea as hysterical, dramatic, mocking and mocking. But I listened carefully. It’s not just a cry for help. It condemns the way we treat people with emotional distress.
Perhaps nothing on the web today celebrates Sinead more than Amanda Palmer’s work. here. And I would like to add to it by remembering her experiences reflected in this video. That she was persecuted in many ways by her prejudices and psychiatry. “A thousand paper cuts will kill you,” says Mr. Palmer. Like many of us loud, angry women trapped in a broken system of mental health, I certainly have days when I can relate.
In the video, she begs for a little sympathy and asks why we treat each other this way. She gives a voice to all those labeled as the neglected and mentally ill, and how she stands in solidarity with others in her cry for justice and compassion for herself. is shown. She was crying for an abandoned woman a few hotel rooms away.
I listened to the video again the day after her death was announced. The video was released shortly after her son died by suicide in 2022. It reminds me of how the members of the hikikomori community tried desperately to get the help they needed, but never found it. There is a lot of prejudice, isolation and loneliness, not only from the medical community, but also from family and friends.
Therefore, at her tragic death, I have chosen to honor her by taking these words she said, and by listening and believing them. In this interview Dr. Philafter having a hysterectomy, was not given hormonal replacements, but after making her graphic and very forceful plea to her family, he told her that he had a mental illness. When asked if he thought
“No, unless you consider complex post-traumatic stress to be a mental illness,” she said confidently.
I often remind people of this. How labels of mental illness, such as depression and bipolar disorder, can also be used to mask the effects of the abuse and trauma that Sinead said she had experienced a lot in her life. As Sinead also notes, such diagnoses are often used to ignore someone’s feelings.
American author and queer activist Glennon Doyle raised an important point to remember when talking about people perceived as mentally ill, victims of abuse, trauma, and even political targeting.she wrote on twitter, “Why is everyone saying Sinead ‘fought his own demons’? She was one of the few brave men who could fight real demons: those who plunder children, those who guarded them in the name of God, their homophobia, their murderous greed… she. fought demons, yes, but they were us, not her. Sinead’s struggles were very real and not something that should be ignored by labeling her as her mental illness. It’s not our society or the injustice she fought, it’s her body, her biology.
There are many instances of Sinead referring to herself as being mentally ill, but she also said in an article that she was misdiagnosed with bipolar disorder. irish mirror. She spoke about the impact of prescription psychiatric drugs on her life and hormonal health. tired to the extreme. Ironically, very depressing. They can trigger thoughts like suicide or self-harm. The menstrual cycle is severely disrupted and can be impotent for a week. “
I hope others can understand how common suicidal thoughts are, not only in the context of trauma and drug side effects, but especially among trauma survivors (including veterans). We want to honor her by supporting her. And remember how being able to talk about suicidal thoughts without the stigma, diagnosis or threat of incarceration in a mental hospital helps people stay alive and heal. There are resources aimed at removing stigma, such as “Alternatives to Suicide.”You can find more information here.
We are also reminded that the best thing we can do for the people we love is to let them talk about their feelings without pathologizing them or labeling them as symptoms of an illness. I would like to. to honor their suffering. to hear.
Sinead was a warrior and in many ways paid the ultimate price for her bravery. Despite being vilified by the public and media for violent protests, denounced and ignored as an angry woman labeled mentally ill, her songs reflect her courageous, vulnerable openness, and It shows her willingness to tell the truth for others. As she said in a 2017 video, “I hope this helps others in some way,” and that’s what brave artists do, and they, no matter how ugly, It reveals the inner truths we usually overlook, such as political truths, injustices, and pain. they make beautiful songs.
In keeping with the spirit of MIA’s Song of the Week feature, I believe that her beautiful compositions and lyrics reveal the human experience of emotional pain, trauma, love, loss, and healing. I created a playlist for Art and music is where healing happens for all of us when warriors like her sing from their hearts. We are lucky to have her work and her presence in our time.
I don’t know if there is a special place to go to find peace after an artist passes away, after honoring the deals we made to create work like the one she did, but I know she I hope you are there and are at peace with your son. That healing room.
****
Press the play button below. Each song in this playlist follows the last song. Songs include: three babies, prewar liquor, Thank you for listening, in this heart, Just like U Said It Could B, The Healing Room, Feel So Different.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=videoseries
